Cant Keep a Good Mare Down
See how mares have become champions at the highest levels of dressage, show jumping, and 3-day eventingTSF Dalera BB and Jessica Von Bredow-Werndl showed the world what a good mare can do by winning four gold medals in consecutive Olympic Games. | Photo: FEI/Benjamin ClarkIn 2024 the Trakehner mare TSF Dalera BB and Jessica Von Bredow-Werndl won both the individual gold medal and team gold medal (for Germany) at the Paris Olympics. Just three years earlier they achieved the same feat in the Tokyo Olympics.There was a time not so long ago that mares were rarely seen winning at the highest levels of dressage, show jumping, and eventing. That seems to be changing, with mares becoming more competitive against geldings and stallions. But what has made these mares so successful? Is it the breeding? The training? The care and management? Experts shed some light on why mares can be such successful partners.Early Show Jumping Successes by MaresPrior to 2000 a mare as an Olympic champion was scarce. The first notable standout was a Standardbred-cross named Halla, ridden by Hans Gnter Winkler of Germany. At the 1956 Olympics in Stockholm, the pair won both individual and team gold medals in show jumping. Four years later in Rome, they were part of the German gold medal show jumping team. Halla remains the only horse to win three Olympic gold medals in show jumping.The diminutive Thoroughbred mare Touch Of Class gained more widespread recognition. Under the name Stillaspill, she went unplaced in six starts on the racetrack. Her fame came as a U.S. show jumper when she and rider Joe Fargis cleared 90 out of 91 jumps in all the show jumping rounds en route to winning individual and team gold medals at the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles.Whether due to training, limited opportunities for mares to compete, or other factors, mares simply didnt appear among the winners at the highest levels.Physiological Differences Between the Equine SexesThe major difference is of course related to hormonal levels, says Tim Worden, PhD, an equestrian sport scientist located in Toronto, Ontario. Stallions will have much higher levels of systemic testosterone than mares, while testosterone is quite limited in geldings. In mares, estrogen and progesterone play a major role in reproductive health in addition to some secondary functions. It is fair to assume that these hormonal differences will impact how each horses body will respond to athletic training to some extent.Researchers studying Thoroughbreds have also demonstrated a difference in heart size between sexes, with male horses tending to have larger hearts than females (even when correcting for body size). Scientists have hypothesized that the difference could lead to a higher VO2max (the maximum amount of oxygen a horse can utilize during intense exercise), he says, which could improve performance.It is important to note that the physiological differences between stallions, geldings, and mares seem to result in far smaller performance differences as compared to humans, Worden says. In racing Quarter Horses, for example, researchers have found males to be significantly faster than females, but only by 0.7%. Similarly, in (Thoroughbred racehorses), stallions were faster than mares by 0.7%, but mares and geldings were not different. In Standardbreds researchers saw a speed difference between pacing stallions and mares of 1.5% but none between stallions, geldings, and mares in trotters. In contrast, elite human male athletes are approximately 10% faster than female athletes in running events.From an evolutionary point of view, physiological differences between male and female humans would make sense. Humans were hunter gatherers, with males and females having different roles in those societies. Conversely, as prey animals, horses needed to evolve to maximize running speed and athleticism to evade predators, and both sexes would need to be highly capable in these abilities, says Worden.What About Muscle Mass?Worden says with factors such as age, performance level, and breed being equal, researchers have found stallions have more muscle than mares. However, some muscles might vary significantly in size, while others show no difference. He also points out that muscle size and force-generating potential represent just one aspect of athletic ability.Muscle mass and maximal force generation are not what limit performance in todays Olympic disciplines, he says. A horses ability to accurately perceive relevant information from the environment, properly respond to the riders cues, and efficiently execute the movements required are all vital to success.Are Mares More Difficult to Train?Whether deserved or not, some people will not acquire or ride a mare because they feel mares are too difficult. Ive had the chance to speak with a lot of leading trainers and riders about this topic and their experience with different horses, says Worden. If I can summarize their views, mares are not necessarily more difficult, but they do require a different approach. They tend to be more reactive than geldings and may give a strong, resistive response when feeling threatened. He stresses the importance of not pushing them too quickly and understanding when mares say no.If mares are resisting completing an action, they will continue to avoid until the negative stimulus is removed, he explains. To counter this in training, regardless of sex, Worden stresses a thoughtful approach that builds trust in the handler or rider. Many small wins put together over time build confident and capable horses, he says.Von Bredow-Werndl agrees. Mares are often known for their sensitivity and work ethic, qualities that are necessary for the development of horses in dressage.Worden also reflects on the history of training horses. When you read through the old training textbooks and manuals, much of that style of training originated in military settings, he says. And in these military settings geldings were often the preferred mounts . For a long time, the prevailing training philosophies were optimized to match the developmental timeline and behavioral nuances of geldings (and stallions), while mares were an afterthought.As horsemen and -women passed these training methods on to the next generation of riders and trainers, those approaches might not have worked as well when applied to mares, hence the notion that mares could be challenging to train.In the last 20 years training has become much more personalized for horsesthe top programs prioritize listening to the horses and being flexible in their training approaches, depending on what each horse needs, says Worden. Everyone involved with the horses, from grooms to riders to trainers, closely observes them for signs of soreness, shifts in behavior, and changes in appetite. Thus, I think we are finally starting to learn how to train mares (and all horses) better.Also, if you look at how sports are evolving, we are maybe seeing a shift that can favor the skills and physique that mares possess, he adds. In show jumping, as courses become more technical and faster, mares are well suited for these demands due to their slightly smaller stature, reactive personality traits, and explosiveness.Von Bredow-Werndl adds, Training methods that emphasize understanding the horses individual nature have also contributed. We prioritize their mental and physical well-being to help them develop as healthy and happy athletes, supported by proper management and care that allow them to perform at their best.Establishing a consistent and structured training routine can help mares feel more secure and condent, says Gail Hoff, PhD, USEF S dressage judge, R dressage sport horse breeding judge, and R Western dressage judge based at Los Alamos Dressage Center, in Ojai, California. She suggests regular sessions where the rider or trainer has clear objectives and expectations. This can improve a mares focus and responsiveness. Incorporating a variety of training exercises and activities can keep them engaged and interested in the training process, she adds.Using positive reinforcement such as a well timed scratch on the neck or verbal praise can reinforce desired behaviors, motivate mares to engage in training activities, and help build trust between horse and rider, she adds.Hoff also recommends providing clear and consistent signals using light aids and clear body language to effectively communicate with mares.What About Breeding?Most internationally competitive horses are European Warmbloods. The registries require horses to be approved to be included in their respective registries. Frozen semen from leading stallions helps breeders select stallions that complement their mares qualities, says Hoff. These programs have dramatically improved the quality and abilities of sport horses.When breeders allow youngsters to grow up as horses (i.e., with ample turnout and not managed intensively) while still interacting with people, they tend to be healthier and more relaxed, says Worden.Competitive Mares Reaching International SuccessIn the past 25 years more mares have won at the highest levels. Two notable horses in dressage include Brentina, a 1991 Hanoverian mare ridden by Debbie McDonald and part of the U.S. bronze medal winning team at the 2004 Athens Olympics, and Isabell Werths mount Weihegold OLD from Germany. The Oldenburg mare won three straight FEI Dressage World CupTM Finals as well as team gold and individual silver at the Rio Olympics in 2016.United States show jumping rider McLain Ward has found great success with two mares. The first, Sapphire, a 1995 Belgian Warmblood, was part of the U.S. team that took home gold in the 2008 Beijing Olympics. He and his next standout mare, HH Azur, a 2006 Belgian Sport Horse, were part of the silver-medal-winning team in Rio. They also won the Rolex CSI5* grand prix at Geneva and Rolex CSI5* grand prix at the Dutch Masters before Ward retired HH Azur in the summer of 2023.The sport of eventing challenges horses and riders on every level. From Australia, the mare Headley Britannia, ridden by Lucinda Fredericks, earned a team silver medal at the 2008 Beijing Olympics, but that isnt her major claim to fame. The 15.3-hand Thoroughbred/Irish Draught cross is the only mare in history to win all three competitions included in the one-time Rolex Grand Slam of eventingBurghley (2006), Badminton (2007), and Kentucky (2009). Many in the eventing discipline consider these competitions to be the most challenging in the world.Another accomplished eventing mare, On Cue, a 2006 mare registered in the Anglo European Studbook, finished fourth in the 2021 Kentucky 3-Day Event CCI5*-L and followed that up with a win in the inaugural Maryland CCI5*-L. She finished 10th at Burghley in 2023 before her retirement.Keeping Mares Happy in WorkWhile these mares and more have reached international success, they all have challenges to overcome. I think we have found a nice balance of listening to horses more in training and putting them in environments where they can excel, but there are still mares that may experience pain or behavioral issues when they are in heat, or other issues that may arise at different times during the reproductive cycle, says Worden.Hoff agrees, saying that hormonal cycles barely bother some mares, but others become too sensitive and resistant to leg aids.Vets and horse owners can use medications to control heat cycles. Meanwhile, embryo transfer allows top mares to reproduce and compete simultaneously. Consequently some breeders are more willing to allow their best mares to be trained and to compete while also producing offspring, says Hoff.Even with medication and management some mares still struggle. If thats the case, Worden believes they cant go to the top. In this group of mares, it becomes impossible to plan and work around these issues, he says.Horses are individuals, and every mare is different. It is up to the caregivers to learn what allows them to relax and be content and to reinforce those aspects, notes Worden. He says he believes riders need to be more flexible in their training and adjust it to match what the horses can do.Ensuring the mares physical and emotional needs are met is crucial for her overall well-being and trainability, says Hoff. Providing proper nutrition, regular exercise, social interaction, and mental stimulation can contribute to a mares readiness and willingness to learn.Worden says if a mare seems unhappy or uncomfortable, the owner or trainer should track the behaviors in detailed notes and discuss with the veterinarian what options could improve the situation.Take-Home MessageIn recent decades, as our understanding of behavior, advancements in supportive management, and attention to horses as individuals have increased, so have mares successes in elite competitions.When such a bond (between horse and rider) is formed, a mare will try her best to do what is asked of her, and she will often outshine her competition, says Hoff. Von Bredow-Werndl says she believes this trend will continue. Riders recognize the unique strengths mares possess, she says. With continued focus on their needs and well-being through training and care, Im certain they will keep achieving remarkable success on the international stage.This article is from the Summer 2025 issue ofThe Horse: Your Guide to Equine Health Care. We at The Horse work to provide you with the latest and most reliable news and information on equine health, care, management, and welfare through our magazine and TheHorse.com. Your subscription helps The Horse continue to offer this vital resource to horse owners of all breeds, disciplines, and experience levels. To access current issues included in your subscription, please sign in to theAppleorGoogleapps ORclick herefor the desktop version.